EDWARD:
Pro: Edward can offer Bella eternal life. She will never get old and they will always be together.
Con: Edward is dead.
Pro: Edward gets all disco sparkly in the sunlight.
Con: Disco is dead.
Pro: There wouldn't be much of a clothing bill since Edward really doesn't need clothes to keep warm.
Con: The pancake makeup and orange lip gloss could become a real budget buster.
Pro: No cooking EVER!
Con: No eating EVER!
Pro: Edward lives in a beautiful house.
Con: Yeah, a house with no beds.
Pro: Edward will never age.
Con: Bella will have to spend eternity with a high school student.
JACOB:
Pro: Jacob in his werewolf form can be warm and cuddly.
Con: Taking werewolf Jacob for a walk and having to "clean up" after him is sure to put a strain on the relationship.
Pro: Jacob is a real "Meat and Potatoes" man (minus the potatoes) and he will always be able to provide food for the table on a moment's notice.
Con: Bella shouldn't expect much support if she decides to become a vegan.
Pro: Jacob has a big family so Bella won't ever be lonely.
Con: All the male members of the family waltz around bare-chested (wait a minute, that's a "Pro!").
Pro: Jacob is just so adorable as a wolf.
Con: Not so adorable is when he does the "butt-walk" across your carpet.
Pro: The werewolves are much bigger than real wolves thus providing maximum protection.
Con: Their size becomes a detriment at worming time.
AND THE FINAL, MOST IMPORTANT COMPARISON
Pro: Jacob is ALIVE!
Con: Edward is DEAD!
There is NO COMPARISON!! Edwardddd!